Friday Happy Hour Review: Elizabeth’s Bar & Restaurant

PLUS … OR MINUS?!
Should You Add Elizabeth’s in East Windsor To Your Happy Hour List
Or Subtract It?

April 3, 2019

For a long list of reasons, I felt like staying close to home for my Happy Hour Review this past Friday, so I decided to check out Elizabeth’s Bar & Restaurant at 4 Prospect Hill Road (Route 5) in East Windsor, CT. A relative newcomer to the area, it opened last year and is the second in a chain of 3 restaurants (the others are in Rocky Hill and Bloomfield). Suggested as a good place to check out by some friends, it proved to be a surprising experience.

THE VIBE:
Decorated With Smiles, It Grows On You

Elizabeth’s Bar & Restaurant
4 Prospect Hill Road, East Windsor, CT

Behind a generic, but attractive exterior, Elizabeth’s still looks and feels fairly new inside. With clean lines, neutral hues and lots of windows, the decor was bright and reasonably cheerful, if stylistically uninspired. The bar itself was a large square with terminals and liquors in the center and plenty of seating. It even had a raised section on one end, which added a new dimension of interest. And, while the décor may have a lacked a definitive identity, there was definitely a warm personality reflected in the smiles of the staff and some of guests who came in while I was there. Over the course of my 90-minute visit, it came to feel quite comfortable and welcoming! And that kind of vibe is hard to beat.

* The only real negative I could find here was the lack of purse hooks underneath the bar, which cost them a point.

A near perfect score on atmosphere is always a good start.

SCORING: THE VIBE 
(ATMOSPHERE –
Maximum of 20 Pts.)
• Style _5_(1-5)
• Layout _4_(1-5) 
• Cleanliness _5_ (1-5)
• Mood _5_ (1-5)
TOTAL VIBE SCORE _19_

THE HEARTBEAT:
Aside From One Skipped Beat,
The Pulse Was Strong

Nicole & Rich
My Bartenders @ Elizabeth’s

As I say every time, I consider the service as the heart and soul of any Happy Hour. Here was a case where it started okay, hit a bump, and then rebounded to finish super strong. I was served by 2 bartenders, Rich and Nicole, who were both very friendly and made me feel very welcome. My first Margarita was delivered promptly by Rich, but as I finished my drink there was an apparent shift change involving closing out a cash drawer and more bartenders coming on duty to deal with a growing number of people at the bar and to make drinks for the service bar. During this transition period my glass was empty, and I waited an unacceptable amount  of time for anyone to notice and ask if I needed a refill. At that point, I was ready to lower their service score considerably, but then Nicole brought these amazing rolls to go along with the to-die-for calamari, which I will write about in glorious detail under THE BITES, and I started mellowing from The Wicked Witch of The West to Mary Poppins. Other than the one blip, the service truly was attentive. Plus, I don’t think I saw anyone not smiling.

In the end, the service finished strong for a nearly perfect score.

SCORING:
THE HEARTBEAT (SERVICE – 
Maximum of 20 Pts.)
• Attitude _5_(1-5)
• Attentive/Responsive _4_(1-5)
• Helpfulness _5_(1-5)
• Efficiency _5_(1-5)
TOTAL HEARTBEAT SCORE _19_

THE DRINKS:
One Cocktail Choice
Does Not Make A Happy Hour

Elizabeth’s Happy Hour Drink Menu

I’ll be blunt … they’re missing the boat at Elizabeth’s by just having a Margarita as the only cocktail on their Happy Hour menu! And, it’s the easiest thing to fix. They need to give the bartenders a chance to showcase their innovative mixology skills in creating several new martinis, mules or other cocktails that will tempt existing customers and attract new ones. Or maybe just add some unique flavors to their Margarita selection like a Razzy ‘Rita or a Mango Tango ‘Rita … anything that’s fun and different. Four different cocktails would be enough to make Elizabeth’s a lot more competitive with Manchester/South Windsor and even West Hartford.

The Margaritas I had were excellent despite being made with a mix. Most sour mixes usually taste awful and give me heartburn, but not this time. So, kudos on the tasty Margaritas and the flexible straws (a nice touch). Now, if you’re into beer, not many places have Peroni (an Italian beer) on draft. I actually used to like Peroni back in the days when I could drink beer. 

Unfortunately, lack of unique or even additional mundane cocktail choices hurt Elizabeth’s scoring in this category.

SCORING: THE SIPS 
(DRINKS – 
Maximum of 20 Pts.)
• Selection _2_(1-5) 
• Unique Options _1_(1-5)
• Pricing _5_(1-5)
• Quality/Taste _5_(1-5)
TOTAL SIPS SCORE _13_

THE BITES:
My Taste Buds Were In Heaven

Elizabeth’s Happy Hour Food Menu

Forgive me if I gush over the food part of Elizabeth’s Happy Hour menu, but the selection set an impressively high standard that’s easily on par with many of the more metropolitan Happy Hours, like those in Manchester/South Windsor and West Hartford. The items on this menu were intriguing (Mussels Fra Diavolo) and substantial (judging by my calamari). Speaking of the calamari, Elizabeth’s was as good as it gets with a very generous portion of lightly coated and lightly-fried-to-perfection rings and tentacles. Tender with a high proportion of rings to tentacles and accompanied by an excellent marinara sauce, it equaled any I have had (and I am a calamari connoisseur)! I have high expectations for the calamari in any place that stresses Italian cuisine and Elizabeth’s did not disappoint.

Elizabeth;s Calamari
A generous portion that was perfectly prepared!

I also have to rave about the rolls that Nicole brought me. It was a basket of three freshly baked rolls with a tray of 3 accompaniments/toppings/dipping oil that transcended the ordinary. Oh, how I love good bread/rolls (even if my scale doesn’t the next day) and Elizabeth’s had my taste buds smiling with joy.

Elizabeth’s Delicious Freshly-Baked Rolls

There is no question that Elizabeth’s Happy Hour food menu deserves a perfect score!

SCORING: THE BITES 
(FOOD – 

Maximum of 20 Pts.)
• Selection _5_(1-5)
• Unique Options _5_(1-5)
• Pricing _5_(1-5)
• Quality/Taste _5_(1-5)
TOTAL BITES SCORE _20_

OVERALL IMPRESSION:
Elizabeth’s Happy Hour Is A Definite Plus 
And Should Be Added To Your
List Of Places To Check Out

This review presented me with a bit of a conundrum in that I really wanted to give them a Top Shelf rating even though the numeric rating came in a point shy of that, which is one of the reasons I went to this system. It sets the criteria that I need to follow in order to assure that every Happy Hour is held to the same standard. With that said, Elizabeth’s rates as a Good Choice that is Well Recommended, which is the second highest rating. However, because I was so impressed with the staff and the food, I’m going to interject here that it’s a “VERY” Good Choice, assuming that you like Margaritas, and you should definitely check out Elizabeth’s in East Windsor for yourself!

TOTAL SCORE _71_ 
RESULT

TOP SHELF (HIGHLY RECOMMENDED) ___ (72-80) 
GOOD CHOICE (WELL RECOMMENDED) _X__ (64-71) 
• DECENT (STANDARD) ___ (52-63) 
AVERAGE (LAST RESORT) ___ (48-51)
AVOID (THE BOTTOM) ___ (<48) 

If you’d like to check out Elizabeth’s Bar & Restaurant in East Windsor and judge for yourself, you can visit their website for hours and more information!

As always, I welcome your comments about this review or any of my blog posts, especially your own experiences at Happy Hours I have reviewed and suggestions about which Happy Hours I should check out next.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *