New Friday Happy Hour Review Scoring System

After all the bar reviews of 2018, I feel like there needs to be some refinement of how I rate each Happy Hour. It has occurred to me that the four existing categories — Uniquely Recommended, Highly Recommended, Recommended W/ Caveats and Not Recommended –need to be reworked based on a scoring system. Of course, it’s a work in progress so I will be phasing in the new system side-by-side with the old system for the next few months, especially for fairness in comparisons, since many of the bars are in areas where their competition has already been reviewed by me under the original system.

The main reasons for this change are: (1) to better identify where a particular bar/happy hour excels or falls short so you can better decide on which ones to try first, and (2) to help bar owners/managers understand what could be improved and what is actually working well (from a consumer perspective).

Even as the categories and numerical measurements may change as I further refine my rating system, there are several points to keep in mind whether you are reading my reviews from a consumer perspective or an owner/manager/bartender perspective:

• Perception is a reality for a consumer, and I do my reviews primarily as a consumer who happens to enjoy mixed drinks.

• Currently, my reviews are based on my experience at a certain time on one Friday night, so your experience may vary more than typical. Once, I start going back to places for a second review, there will be a better baseline for determining consistency of the experience.

• My goal is not to make news with bad reviews. My goal is to honestly review a Friday Happy Hour and let people know if I think it’s worth their time and why. Undeservedly bad or good reviews could destroy my credibility, so my key focus is to give my unbiased opinions based on actual experience.


A. THE VIBE (ATMOSPHERE – Maximum of 20 Pts.)

(Is the environment inviting, comfortable, clean, easy to navigate, etc.?)

• Style __ (1-5)
• Layout __ (1-5)
• Cleanliness __ (1-5)
• Mood __ (1-5)

B. THE HEARTBEAT (SERVICE – Maximum of 20 Pts.)

(Is the service prompt, efficient, accommodating and pleasant?)

• Attitude __ (1-5)
• Attentive/Responsive __ (1-5)
• Helpfulness __ (1-5)
• Efficiency __ (1-5)

C. THE SIPS (DRINKS – Maximum of 20 Pts.)

(Are there interesting and tasty choices at a good price?)

• Selection __ (1-5)
• Unique Options __ (1-5)
• Pricing __ (1-5)
• Quality/Taste __ (1-5)

D. THE BITES (FOOD – Maximum of 20 Pts.)

(Are there unique options for a variety of tastes at a reasonable price?)

• Selection __ (1-5)
• Unique Options __ (1-5)
• Pricing __ (1-5)
• Quality/Taste __ (1-5)

E. Overall Impressions

(Summation of points rating along with a plus or minus based on any good or bad things encountered not otherwise rated, Overall Recommendation and Summation)

• TOP SHELF (HIGHLY RECOMMENDED) ___ (72-80) (OLD Uniquely Recommended)
• GOOD CHOICE (WELL RECOMMENDED) ___ (64-71) (OLD Recommended W/O Reservations)
• DECENT (STANDARD) ___ (52-63) (OLD Recommended W/Caveats)
• AVOID (THE BOTTOM) ___ (<48) (OLD Not Recommended)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *